From LAN To Scam? – Regulating Cyber Cafes

Cyber cafes (aka LAN Houses) in Brazil are omnipresent and currently make up 48% of all internet access points by Brazilians. Just to give a rough idea of their popularity, there are an estimated 108,000 cyber cafes in Brazil while the number of bookstores in the country is below 3,000.

A new law (in Portuguese) recently approved by Brazil’s Federal Court, and awaiting approval by the Senate, will require the 32 million Brazilians that currently use LAN houses to register themselves before being allowed to get online. Under the guise of protecting the underage crowd from accessing explicit content, every client’s digital footprints will be tracked. In exchange, the “digital inclusion centers” (as LAN houses have been deemed by the government) will be able to open lines of credit for the purchasing of new equipment.

Although the types of fines to be imposed for those who ignore the law have yet to be determined, according a report by the newspaper Folha, 90% of all LAN houses in the country are unlicensed. In light of such a figure, the new oversight begins to look like a thinly-veiled attempt to track and control both cyber cafes and their customers.

As I mentioned in a blog post more than a year ago, almost all cyber cafe users I’ve ever seen while living in Brazil are males in their teens who go there to use MSN and play popular shoot ’em up video games. Why they or anyone else need to be tracked is beyond my comprehension, though the idea does cross my mind that the new law will make many more businesses indebted to credit card companies or the like as well as increase, rather than decrease, the general hourly cost to the client for accessing the Internet.

This past January saw a precedent being made by Anatel (Brazil’s National Telecommunications Agency) when they gave a resident of Teresina, in the state of Piauí, a fine of almost US$2,000. His crime? “Acting as a service provider” when he shared his wi-fi connection with a few neighbors for the price of a fraction of his monthly bill. To put it in other words, the “criminal” was acting like an unlicensed LAN house.

Like most laws in most countries across the world, it is my opinion that their purpose is to collect revenue for the State by determining not what is right or wrong, but what is legal and illegal based on how those in power define such terms. As for where these tactics leave Brazilians, I assume they will either open their wallets (to pay higher prices and to show their identification) or find ways to make informal LAN houses even more informal by going “underground”.

Originally written for Street Smart Brazil

2 thoughts on “From LAN To Scam? – Regulating Cyber Cafes

  1. Desculpe responder em português. A função da lei em parte é arrecadar dinheiro para o estado, mas tem o propósito também de facilitar a identificação de pedófilos.

    LAN Houses são usadas por pedófilos que acessam redes sociais para “aliciar” crianças/ publicar e acessar pornografia infantil, e a policia não tem como rastrear qualquer acesso a partir delas.

    Pode ser que houvesse um meio melhor de controlar esse mal uso das LAN Houses sem que a imensa maioria tivesse que “pagar” por alguns…

    • Oi JE

      Espero que a popularidade de LAN Houses caia nos anos que vem, especialmente considerando que o preço de computadores está caindo com a introdução de tablets e netbooks no país. Pedófilos sempre vão existir e só iriam para mais um lugar para continuar fazendo o que fazem então rastejar todo o mundo não faz sentido nesse cenário.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s